The Indy 500 is chock full of tradition, but only one driver gets to participate in getting a whole bottle of chilled milk effectively thrown in their face.
The practice has topped off every race since 1956, but its roots actually run deeper. The images are iconic, and this year, someone else will get to make the all-important choice: whole, 2 percent, or skim?
Why does the Indianapolis 500 winner drink milk?
Like any great story, this one has escalation. Louis Meyer began the hallowed tradition of milk drinking after his second Indy 500 win in 1933. He sipped from a glass of milk, saying his mother had told him a glass of buttermilk was the best thing to drink on a hot day.
MORE: Indy 500 qualifying results: Pole, starting lineup for 2022 race at Indianapolis
After his third win in 1936, Meyer abandoned all sense of decorum. He took a swig of milk straight from the bottle, likely disgusting everyone there rather than inspiring awe. A photographer snapped a picture of Meyer drinking said milk, and it spawned a tradition like no other.
It wasn’t until 1956, however, that the practice truly took hold. Drivers now do it every year, but between 1946 and 1955 there was a hiatus. Today, every driver is polled before the race on their preference, and they can choose from among whole, 2 percent, and skim milk.
Why did Emmerson Fittipaldi drink orange juice?
One driver decided to get cute with the tradition, and as George Bluth Sr. would say, it may have resulted in some light treason.
Emmerson Fittipaldi, who owns an orange grove, drank orange juice in the winner’s circle in 1993 before quickly chasing it with the traditional milk. Not for nothing, but that is a disgusting combination.
Fittipaldi was booed for his crimes, but he got the last laugh. He was honored by the American Dairy Association of Indiana last year. Let no one accuse our Big Milk overlords of not having a sense a humor.
Can drivers drink buttermilk?
The real question here is: Do drivers want to drink buttermilk? Buttermilk isn’t made the same way it once was. It now has a sour taste to it that is not particularly palatable as it has become mass-produced.
According to the Indy Star, drivers will have to prove their mettle before having buttermilk.
“(If) we see a driver drink a full glass of buttermilk before the race,” American Dairy Association of Indiana’s Brooke Williams said to the Star, “we’ll give them some special (consideration). For now, we’re keeping it to the three options (of whole, 2 percent, or skim).”
What milk did drivers select for 2022?
Drivers’ picks are in for 2022. Here’s what every driver would be drinking in the winner’s circle, should they win the race (along with their additional comments in parentheses).
Driver comment tiers
Adorably polite: Jimmie Johnson
Pink powder?: Helio Castroneves
Firm, but respectful: Alex Palau, Devlin DeFrancesco, Kyle Kirkwood, Dalton Kellett, Colton Herta, Santino Ferucci
Bordering on rude: Scott McLaughlin
Buttermilk: Felix Rosenqvist, Ed Carpenter
Weirdly passive aggressive: Graham Rahal
Cheeky: Marco Andretti
Lying about not having a preference: Juan Pablo Montoya
Indy 500 winners since 2010
